我列出了一些元素,可以使用轻松进行比较Equals()。我必须对列表进行混洗,但是混洗必须满足一个条件:
Equals()
第i个元素shuffledList[i]不得等于i +/- 1或处的元素i +/- 2。该清单应视为通函;也就是说,列表中的最后一个元素之后是第一个元素,反之亦然。
shuffledList[i]
i +/- 1
i +/- 2
另外,如果可能的话,我想检查一下是否有可能进行改组。
我正在使用c#4.0。
根据一些回答,我将解释更多:
该列表不会包含200个以上的元素,因此并不需要真正的性能。如果要花2秒钟来计算,那不是最好的事情,但这也不是世界末日。混排的列表将被保存,除非实际列表更改,否则将使用混排的列表。
是的,这是“受控”的随机性,但是我希望在此方法上运行的多个对象将返回不同的混排列表。
在尝试以下一些响应后,我将做进一步的编辑。
样本1:
`List<int> list1 = new List<int>{0,1,1,1,2,2,2,3,3,3,4,4,4,5,5,6,6,6,7,7,7,7,8,8,8,8,9,9,9,9,9,10};`
可能的解决方案:
List<int> shuffledList1 = new List<int> {9,3,1,4,7,9,2,6,8,1,4,9,2,0,6,5,7,8,4,3,10,9,6,7,8,5,3,9,1,2,7,8}
范例2:
`List<int> list2 = new List<int> {0,1,1,2,2,2,3,3,4,4,4,4,5,5,5,6,6,6,7,7,7,7,8,8,8,8,8,9,9,9,9,10};`
public bool TestShuffle<T>(IEnumerable<T> input) { bool satisfied = true; int prev1 = 0; int prev2 = 0; int next1 = 0; int next2 = 0; int i = 0; while (i < input.Count() && satisfied) { prev1 = i - 1; prev2 = i - 2; next1 = i + 1; next2 = i + 2; if (i == 0) { prev1 = input.Count() - 1; prev2 = prev1 - 1; } else if (i == 1) prev2 = input.Count() - 1; if (i == (input.Count() - 1)) { next1 = 0; next2 = 1; } if (i == (input.Count() - 2)) next2 = 0; satisfied = (!input.ElementAt(i).Equals(input.ElementAt(prev1))) && (!input.ElementAt(i).Equals(input.ElementAt(prev2))) && (!input.ElementAt(i).Equals(input.ElementAt(next1))) && (!input.ElementAt(i).Equals(input.ElementAt(next2))) ; if (satisfied == false) Console.WriteLine("TestShuffle fails at " + i); i++; } return satisfied; }
有时失败的另一个测试输入:
List<int> list3 = new List<int>(){0,1,1,2,2,3,3,3,4,4,4,5,5,5,5,6,6,6,6,7,7,7,8,8,8,8,9,9,9,9,10,10};
令我失望的是,我的优化功能仅比LINQ“简单”版本运行速度快7倍。 未 优化LINQ 1m43s 优化 14.7s 。
-optimize+
TESTITERATIONS
VERBOSE
#define
已优化的内容:
GroupBy
ValueRun
unsafe
MAGIC
这是具有优化版本的代码。_通过消除RNG的播种可以增加速度;这些只是为了使回归测试输出成为可能。
[... old code removed as well ...]
如果我说对了,那么您正在尝试设计一种改组方法,以防止重复项在输出中连续结束(最少交错2个元素)。
在一般情况下,这是无法解决的。想象只有相同元素的输入:)
就像我在笔记中提到的那样,我认为我一直都在走错路。我应该调用图论(有人吗?),或者改用简单的“蛮力”算法,这是Erick的长篇建议。
无论如何,这样您就可以了解我的工作状况以及存在的问题(启用随机样本以快速查看问题):
#define OUTPUT // to display the testcase results #define VERIFY // to selfcheck internals and verify results #define SIMPLERANDOM // #define DEBUG // to really traces the internals using System; using System.Linq; using System.Collections.Generic; public static class Q5899274 { // TEST DRIVER CODE private const int TESTITERATIONS = 100000; public static int Main(string[] args) { var testcases = new [] { new [] {0,1,1,2,2,2,3,3,4,4,4,4,5,5,5,6,6,6,7,7,7,7,8,8,8,8,8,9,9,9,9,10}, new [] {0,1,1,1,2,2,2,3,3,3,4,4,4,5,5,6,6,6,7,7,7,7,8,8,8,8,9,9,9,9,9,10}, new [] { 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41, 42, 42, 42, }, new [] {1,1,1,1,2,2,2,2,3,3,3,3,4,4,4,4}, }.AsEnumerable(); // // creating some very random testcases // testcases = Enumerable.Range(0, 10000).Select(nr => Enumerable.Range(GROUPWIDTH, _seeder.Next(GROUPWIDTH, 400)).Select(el => _seeder.Next(-40, 40)).ToArray()); foreach (var testcase in testcases) { // _seeder = new Random(45); for (int i=0; i<TESTITERATIONS; i++) // for benchmarking/regression { try { var output = TestOptimized(testcase); #if OUTPUT Console.WriteLine("spread\t{0}", string.Join(", ", output)); #endif #if VERIFY AssertValidOutput(output); #endif } catch(Exception e) { Console.Error.WriteLine("Exception for input {0}:", string.Join(", ", testcase)); Console.Error.WriteLine("Sequence length {0}: {1} groups and remainder {2}", testcase.Count(), (testcase.Count()+GROUPWIDTH-1)/GROUPWIDTH, testcase.Count() % GROUPWIDTH); Console.Error.WriteLine("Analysis: \n\t{0}", string.Join("\n\t", InternalAnalyzeInputRuns(testcase))); Console.Error.WriteLine(e); } } } return 0; } #region Algorithm Core const int GROUPWIDTH = 3; /* implying a minimum distance of 2 (GROUPWIDTH-1) values in between duplicates must be guaranteed*/ public static T[] TestOptimized<T>(T[] input, bool doShuffle = false) where T: IComparable<T> { if (input.Length==0) return input; var runs = InternalAnalyzeInputRuns(input); #if VERIFY CanBeSatisfied(input.Length, runs); // throws NoValidOrderingExists if not #endif var transpositions = CreateTranspositionIndex(input.Length, runs); int pos = 0; for (int run=0; run<runs.Length; run++) for (int i=0; i<runs[run].runlength; i++) input[transpositions[pos++]] = runs[run].value; return input; } private static ValueRun<T>[] InternalAnalyzeInputRuns<T>(T[] input) { var listOfRuns = new List<ValueRun<T>>(); Array.Sort(input); ValueRun<T> current = new ValueRun<T> { value = input[0], runlength = 1 }; for (int i=1; i<=input.Length; i++) { if (i<input.Length && input[i].Equals(current.value)) current.runlength++; else { listOfRuns.Add(current); if (i<input.Length) current = new ValueRun<T> { value = input[i], runlength = 1 }; } } #if SIMPLERANDOM var rng = new Random(_seeder.Next()); listOfRuns.ForEach(run => run.tag = rng.Next()); // this shuffles them #endif var runs = listOfRuns.ToArray(); Array.Sort(runs); return runs; } // NOTE: suboptimal performance // * some steps can be done inline with CreateTranspositionIndex for // efficiency private class NoValidOrderingExists : Exception { public NoValidOrderingExists(string message) : base(message) { } } private static bool CanBeSatisfied<T>(int length, ValueRun<T>[] runs) { int groups = (length+GROUPWIDTH-1)/GROUPWIDTH; int remainder = length % GROUPWIDTH; // elementary checks if (length<GROUPWIDTH) throw new NoValidOrderingExists(string.Format("Input sequence shorter ({0}) than single group of {1})", length, GROUPWIDTH)); if (runs.Length<GROUPWIDTH) throw new NoValidOrderingExists(string.Format("Insufficient distinct values ({0}) in input sequence to fill a single group of {1})", runs.Length, GROUPWIDTH)); int effectivewidth = Math.Min(GROUPWIDTH, length); // check for a direct exhaustion by repeating a single value more than the available number of groups (for the relevant groupmember if there is a remainder group) for (int groupmember=0; groupmember<effectivewidth; groupmember++) { int capacity = remainder==0? groups : groups -1; if (capacity < runs[groupmember].runlength) throw new NoValidOrderingExists(string.Format("Capacity exceeded on groupmember index {0} with capacity of {1} elements, (runlength {2} in run of '{3}'))", groupmember, capacity, runs[groupmember].runlength, runs[groupmember].value)); } // with the above, no single ValueRun should be a problem; however, due // to space exhaustion duplicates could end up being squeezed into the // 'remainder' group, which could be an incomplete group; // In particular, if the smallest ValueRun (tail) has a runlength>1 // _and_ there is an imcomplete remainder group, there is a problem if (runs.Last().runlength>1 && (0!=remainder)) throw new NoValidOrderingExists("Smallest ValueRun would spill into trailing incomplete group"); return true; } // will also verify solvability of input sequence private static int[] CreateTranspositionIndex<T>(int length, ValueRun<T>[] runs) where T: IComparable<T> { int remainder = length % GROUPWIDTH; int effectivewidth = Math.Min(GROUPWIDTH, length); var transpositions = new int[length]; { int outit = 0; for (int groupmember=0; groupmember<effectivewidth; groupmember++) for (int pos=groupmember; outit<length && pos<(length-remainder) /* avoid the remainder */; pos+=GROUPWIDTH) transpositions[outit++] = pos; while (outit<length) { transpositions[outit] = outit; outit += 1; } #if DEBUG int groups = (length+GROUPWIDTH-1)/GROUPWIDTH; Console.WriteLine("Natural transpositions ({1} elements in {0} groups, remainder {2}): ", groups, length, remainder); Console.WriteLine("\t{0}", string.Join(" ", transpositions)); var sum1 = string.Join(":", Enumerable.Range(0, length)); var sum2 = string.Join(":", transpositions.OrderBy(i=>i)); if (sum1!=sum2) throw new ArgumentException("transpositions do not cover range\n\tsum1 = " + sum1 + "\n\tsum2 = " + sum2); #endif } return transpositions; } #endregion // Algorithm Core #region Utilities private struct ValueRun<T> : IComparable<ValueRun<T>> { public T value; public int runlength; public int tag; // set to random for shuffling public int CompareTo(ValueRun<T> other) { var res = other.runlength.CompareTo(runlength); return 0==res? tag.CompareTo(other.tag) : res; } public override string ToString() { return string.Format("[{0}x {1}]", runlength, value); } } private static /*readonly*/ Random _seeder = new Random(45); #endregion // Utilities #region Error detection/verification public static void AssertValidOutput<T>(IEnumerable<T> output) where T:IComparable<T> { var repl = output.Concat(output.Take(GROUPWIDTH)).ToArray(); for (int i=1; i<repl.Length; i++) for (int j=Math.Max(0, i-(GROUPWIDTH-1)); j<i; j++) if (repl[i].Equals(repl[j])) throw new ArgumentException(String.Format("Improper duplicate distance found: (#{0};#{1}) out of {2}: value is '{3}'", j, i, output.Count(), repl[j])); } #endregion }